This article of Salman
Asif Siddiqui was published in HIBA Magazine in January 2014.
I often ask people, if they had ever thought of committing
suicide in their academic life, and a reasonable number of them say 'yes', even
the ones, who had been high achiever students. According to a study done by National
Institute of Mental Health, USA, suicide is the third leading cause of death in
youngsters aged 15 to 24. Another study, conducted in Australian High Schools on
students aged 12 to 14 years, revealed that students with low self esteem,
depressed mood, and perceptions of failure may be at increased risk for
suicidal thoughts and behaviours. Our children live under enormous pressures
these days. They are on a constant battle to survive against all odds. Almost
every other child in this world undergoes a painful, psychologically uncomfortable
and often dehumanizing experience in order to receive education. I believe there
are at least three kinds of pressures that work upon them; academic pressure,
parental pressure and peer pressure.
How does Academic Pressure work?
The first kind of pressure that works upon our children is
Academic Pressure. They are almost always burdened. They have to carry a bag
filled with six to eight textbooks and notebooks for each subject. Homework is
something that most of them do not enjoy and can not escape from. These poor
children cannot afford to be absent from class, even if they are not well. According
to a survey, children aged between 11 and 14 do an average of three-hour
homework, in order to survive and remain acceptable in their schooling systems.
They carry a bag which is about 40% of their body weight. According to British
Osteopathic Association: ‘Children should never carry more than about 15% of
their own body weight. The long term effects from carrying heavy bags include
strains on the neck and shoulder leading to headaches, fatigue and an early
development of poor posture along with strain to arms and wrists.'
Majority of school going children hardly go for a morning or
evening walk and do not experience the pleasant breeze and fresh oxygen, which is required for better
brain functioning. Almost every second day is a test or some marked assignment.
About 20% of their school days are allocated for exams. In between, there are such
competitions as spelling bee and declamation contests requiring students to
prepare five to six hours a day with immense pressure to win each of them. Tuitions
are a routine, which they have to follow. And there are tests at tuitions, too.
Students, who concentrate on their academics, look too serious, exhausted and
often ignorant about what is happening in the world or in their families. They
tend to forget themselves for the love or fear of exams. All that is important
in their lives is to fulfill the academic demands at any cost. These poor
children receive respect from society on the basis of their academic
performance and not on the basis of their good intentions or great ideas.
It is generally believed that teachers can not contain more
than two subjects, while students are able to accommodate the diverse and often
unconnected pieces of knowledge from eight subjects. Many children face immense
learning difficulties as they are not allowed to express their understanding in
the language they know well. Classwork that is demanded on a particular pace
with a particular level of perfection from every child becomes an instrument of
torture. How awful it is to offer a
break of 20 minutes in a school day of six hours. Sometimes even this twenty minutes
break is withdrawn from a child, who needs additional time for making up the academic
work. If the school is located at a distance, then the travelling time in
school transport adds to their miseries.
How does Parental Pressure work?
Another pressure that badly affects children is Parental
Pressure. I have heard many children saying, ‘I wish I was born free.’ Parents
generally have very high and non-flexible expectations from their children. It
has become hard for many parents to trust their children’s abilities and
intentions, when they fail to do well in exams. In a majority of cases, the relationship
between parents and children relies on the grades the children receive in their
exams, which is so very unfortunate.
Given the above mentioned facts, it appears that children in
today’s world are doing two jobs. They are employed at two places: school and
home. They cannot take a day off at their will and are often not compensated
for their work. They live a life where friendships, questioning,
experimentation and wandering around are hardly appreciated. They are not
encouraged for their natural curiosity and qualities of giving, sharing and
frankness. Instead, they are chained to follow an agenda and a routine that is
set for them without their consent. All children go through this, until they
become able to exercise their own will and experience their independence. But
many poor children are lost in this battle. Their creative spark is successfully
extinguished by the collective efforts of parents and schools.
One of the ambitions of parents is to get their child
admitted into a brand school. Under this vision, mothers start dreaming about
some of the renowned schools already at the time of their pregnancies. Imagine
the terrible pressure the poor child will be born with. She or he will be sent
to preparation centres at the age of two years, in order to pass the entrance
test of his/ her parents’ dream school. Once the child is admitted, the vicious
never-ending cycle of academic stress, competitions and loads of homework is on
the way.
Much of the conversation that takes place between parents
and children is governed by the following questions or instructions: “What
happened in your school today? How was your test today? What grade did you get
in the last paper? What is the homework today? When is the next test? Change
your school uniform. Offer your Salat. Have your lunch and, please, do it
quickly. Get ready for tuition”, etc.
Another form of parental pressure is their demand for
discipline and maintaining a tidy and mess-free home. Girls in particular
become a victim of this wish. In many families, the obsession to tame the
children for manners and obedience in their early childhood supersedes any
other wish of meaningful learning or relationship.
Many parents demand their children to choose a particular professional
field, without considering the child's interests. A majority of parents make
their children realize that they spend a lot of money on their education, and that
children have to pay back through getting good grades. When children somehow
fail to meet the demands of their parents, they feel bad about themselves and
lose self confidence.
How does Peer Pressure work?
Peer Pressure plays a phenomenal role in the lives of
children. Children want to be liked, accepted, and appreciated by their peers
more than any one else in the world. This peer consciousness causes some
positive and negative influences on their personality. They learn from their
peers and become interested in doing things, which are being liked by their
peers. Mark Twain once put it beautifully in his witty style: “I have always
paid the school master for the education of my kids, but these are the school
boys who have taught him.”
Sometimes good habits and trends are initiated and
reinforced by groups of children. while at other times it is vice versa. A
child being a part of his social group gets influenced by his or her peers. At times,
a child may not feel comfortable in
adopting something from the peers. But the fear of being unpopular, disapproved
and rejected by the social group surrounds the child and exert immense pressure
on him/ her.
Although many children experience some sort of peer
pressure, they usually do not realize it. Peer pressure takes a child into a complex
state of varied feelings ranging from fears and rage to hate, hope and jealousy.
If a child is not confident enough, his/ her self image will be severely
influenced by the kind of treatment he/ she receives from the peers. Sometimes,
children stop pursuing their genuine natural interests, because they feel that
they will be ridiculed for their interests. Often, many children tend to do
things which are not of their choice but the desire of the group. Smoking is
one such example, which a lot of boys and girls initiate, in order to look
smart and cool. Sometimes, they smoke to seek additional appreciation from
their peers. For some children, smoking becomes their social passport. Some
children try to impress their peers through smoking or through any other activity,
which is forbidden by the adults.
Peer pressure may be unspoken or unintentional. Sometimes a
child may feel pressured not because peers are asking him to do a certain thing
but the child himself feels that if he will not do a certain thing, he might be
considered silly.
Nobody would like to be rejected by his/ her equals. When
children fail to cope with peer pressures or, in other words, do not conform to
group norms, they isolate themselves or restrict their interaction with few
class fellows. Many do not create friendships; rather, they limit themselves to
acquaintanceships. A reasonable number of children willingly or unwillingly
adopt what is being desired by their peers and conform to group norms.
One of the major causes of negative peer pressure is
comparison between children. Many teachers and parents do it continuously in
subtle ways. Some do it rather explicitly. When we do not recognize children,
as who they really are, and fail to own them unconditionally, they learn to
doubt themselves. Their confidence weakens and they become increasingly
sensitive to the approval from their peers.
How can we reduce Academic Pressure?
- We need to believe that academics is not everything. A successful person is not the one who gets good grades, but a person who is well-rounded, happy and enjoys healthy body and mind with a vision to strive for.
- Schools should reduce the number and size of exams and introduce alternatives to formal testing like portfolio development and mechanism of self-assessment. This will help to eradicate the tuition culture and children will have some free time for family and other meaningful activities.
- Curriculum should be made child-friendly and flexible. There should be more opportunities of recreation and the academic process must capitalize on students’ interests and experiences.
- Early education process must be carried out in the language children are proficient in. Education must not demand a child to switch the medium of his/ her thinking.
- If we cannot reduce the weight of school bags, at least we can replace them by trolley school bags, like it is done by children in Europe .
How can we reduce Parental Pressure?
How can we reduce Peer Pressure?
- Children are born with countless interests. Identify and respect the interests of your children and facilitate them to pursue their interests.
- Learn to trust children unconditionally. Accept your children for what they are. Help your children pursue their dreams, instead of forcing your own vision onto them.
- Never equate your children’s intelligence and creativity with their academic results. Grades tell us nothing about a child’s talents or creative potentials. Appreciate your children for what they do enthusiastically.
- Acknowledge the fact that your children are loaded with work, and that they need some time to relax. Keep an eye on yourself to ensure that you are not the reason for making your child feel burdened.
- Instead of throwing questions on children and asking them to give a report of their day, wait and understand their situation and problems.
- Give children a positive, stress-free and emotionally comfortable environment. They are likely to interact with their peers in a congenial manner when they are relaxed.
- Train children to realize why they feel how they feel. Help them recognize their different states of feelings. They will learn to be empathetic through your wise and friendly facilitation.
- Eliminate all forms of individual competitions and never use individual comparison as a strategy for motivation. In fact, it is something that de-motivates them and above all, affects their relationship with their peers.
- Engage with your child in open and meaningful discussions to prepare them for dealing with the issues they might face in society.
- Make your child exceptionally confident and courageous. Confidence will enable a child to become who he or she really is, without feeling devalued or becoming dependent on the approval of peers.
good artcle
ReplyDeleteread this as a grown adult reflecting on my own childhood experiences. felt a mix of dislike and resentment and a strange sense of comfort and calm all at the same time.
ReplyDelete